New maps from newbie mapping contest

[Masog]

So over a month ago or so I announced a mapping contest for my polish viewers on youtube & twitch and yesterday total of 3 maps were sent to me. I haven't picked a winner yet, would be appreciated if some of you let me know which maps you think are good and which are bad and why. I personally think these maps are actually decent so you might want to consider adding at least some of them to CS:GO map pool (there are no CS:S ports currently and idk if the mappers are going to do that).
I don't have a good enough PC to record videos in best quality but at least you can see how the maps work:
surf_misty_ by FIREK
video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weaLcUwAy3U
download: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=714819380

surf_cylinder_konkurs by Kozaa.
video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tmoxcA_v2u8
download: there's no public download available yet, since the _konkurs in map's name, konkurs = contest in polish. Kozaa is still working on finishing the map.

surf_lightrust_easy by Sheogorath
video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPHWRpMYGc4
download: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=715001773

[Rapha]

i really like surf_cylinder_konkurs by kozaa.

[FIREK]

very nice maps!!

[Nyannix]

surf_lightrust_easy is nice but a little bit too short

[Sacred]

Cylinder looks good, the other two kinda boring.

[Blink]

Misty is straight forward all the way through, there's nothing creative in the map so it's really boring

cylinder look like a playable map, by far the best of these 3. Wouldn't mind if it was added to the server

lightrust stages are too simple and short

[Mooster Cow]

what are those

[THERAPIST]

2nd map easily best, tell him to change the theme so its red + diff color for non-surf rather than just fucking red everywhere though

[rool]

cylinder wins